Model Year Matters

2016 Tesla Model S

Hatchback · 2012–2026

Which year to buy

Too new to judge: 2026. Give a new year a year or two of owner reports.

Used asking price: about $18,700 (average of 63 cars listed since June 2026, about 113,000 miles). Asking prices, not sale prices. Source: ForCar

Bar height: serious owner complaints to NHTSA for that year per car on the road, against this model's usual year.

2016CAREFULSerious complaints 2.3× usual, mostly suspension and steering

443 serious complaints of 649, the most about suspension (211) and steering (87); per car on the road, 2.3× this model's usual year. 10 recalls. NHTSA investigation EA21002: desiccated air bag inflator rupture. NHTSA investigation PE16007: automatic vehicle control systems.

What owners report

“Here is another tesla in the junkyard: https://www.iaai.com/vehicle?itemid=25868188&rownumber=47&loadrecent=true the front suspension has collapsed and the wheel has gone all whompy. The headlamp just forward of the wheel has not been broken. No air-bags have been deployed. Please investigate.”

An owner's complaint to NHTSA about the suspension, Aug 2017

“Another complaint to draw attention to the dangers of autopilot. Here is a video of a driver in europe driving with autopilot hands free on narrow winding roads with pedestrians cyclists and oncoming traffic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=chihrwjddyc none of these road users deserve to have their lives placed at risk.”

An owner's complaint to NHTSA about the steering, Jun 2017

When problems show up

Half of the 273 serious complaints that gave a mileage came before 10,000 miles.

Suspension (149 serious complaints): half came before 10,000 miles; 71% within a typical 36,000-mile new-car warranty.

Steering (64 serious complaints): half came before 5,000 miles; 89% within a typical 36,000-mile new-car warranty.

From owner complaints to NHTSA that gave a mileage.

649 owner complaints · 10 recalls (check a car's VIN for open recalls) · EPA combined: 89–104 mpg · NHTSA: 5 of 5 stars · 2016 trims and features

Every Model S year's verdict

Verdicts computed from NHTSA owner complaints, defect investigations and recalls. Cars on the road from New York State registrations. (How we judge.) Data checked 2026-10-24.

Trims and features

201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026

What changed for 2016

2016 Model S trims

6060D7070D7575D8585D90DP100DP85DP90D
Price
Starting MSRP$66,000$71,000$70,000$75,000$74,500$79,500$80,000$85,000$88,000$134,500$105,000$108,000
Powertrain
Horsepower———329 hp——362 hp422 hp——691 hp—
DrivetrainRWDAWDRWDAWDRWDAWDRWDAWDAWDAWDAWDAWD
Electric range210 mi218 mi234 mi240 mi249 mi259 mi265 mi270 mi294 mi315 mi253 mi270 mi
Performance
0-60 mph (maker's claim)5.5 s5.2 s5.5 s5.2 s—5.2 s5.4 s4.4 s4.2 s2.5 s3.1 s3.1 s
Top speed (maker's claim)———140 mph——140 mph155 mph——155 mph—
Size and capability
Seats555555555555
Tech
Touchscreen17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in
Driver assistance
Adaptive cruise control———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Lane keepingLane Departure WarningLane Departure WarningLane Departure WarningLane Departure Warning + optionLane Departure WarningLane Departure WarningLane Departure Warning + optionLane Departure Warning + optionLane Departure WarningLane Departure WarningLane Departure Warning + optionLane Departure Warning + option
Blind-spot monitoringOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Automatic emergency brakingAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + optionAutomatic Emergency Braking + option
Parking sensorsOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Comfort
Seats———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Heated seats———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Remote startApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote Start
Packages and options (48)
6060D7070D7575D8585D90DP100DP85DP90D
Autopilot Convenience Features ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Ludicrous Speed Upgrade ——————————OptionalOptional
Performance Package ——————————OptionalOptional
Premium Interior and Lighting ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Range Upgrade ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Smart Air Suspension $2,500———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Subzero Weather Package $1,000———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
All Glass Panoramic Roof ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Carbon Fiber Spoiler $1,000——————————OptionalOptional
Tesla Red Brake Calipers ——————————StandardStandard
Phone Dock Kit ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Rear Facing Seats ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Ultra High Fidelity Sound $2,500———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Autopilot Computer (HW1) OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Autopilot Computer (HW2) OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Enhanced Autopilot $5,000———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Full Self-Driving Capability $3,000———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
19" Wheels ———Standard——StandardStandard——StandardStandard
19” Silver Cyclone Wheels $2,500———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
21-inch Grey Turbine Wheels $4,500———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
21” Silver Turbine Wheels $4,500———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Black Alcantara ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Carbon Fiber $1,000———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Glossy Obeche Wood ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Matte Obeche Wood ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Piano Black ———Standard——StandardStandard——StandardStandard
White Alcantara ———Standard——StandardStandard——StandardStandard
Deep Blue Metallic ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Midnight Silver Metallic ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Obsidian Black Metallic ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Pearl White Multi-Coat ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Red Multi-Coat ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Solid Black ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Solid White ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Titanium Metallic ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Black Leather and Alcantara Seats $2,500————————————
Black Multi-Pattern ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Black Tesla Premium Seats $2,500————————————
Grey Leather and Alcantara Seats $2,500————————————
Leather Seats in Black ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Leather Seats in Grey ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Leather Seats in Tan ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Next Generation Seats in Black ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Next Generation Seats in Grey ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Next Generation Seats in Tan ———Optional——OptionalOptional——OptionalOptional
Tan Leather and Alcantara Seats $2,500————————————
Tan Tesla Premium Seats $2,500————————————
Ultra White Tesla Premium Seats $2,500————————————

Trim data from OpenSpec (ODbL 1.0), built from Oem brochure, Oem configurator, Nhtsa vin decode, Nhtsa vin decode, Oem configurator. Still partial for this year: model, trims, powertrain, fuel economy, dimensions, exterior, interior, infotainment, safety, warranty, options, option rules, vin decode. "Optional" means a package or option adds it; tap for which.

Corrected by us: 0-60 mph (and top speed, where shown) as Kelley Blue Book's specs list them for this model year: the maker's figures. Source: Kelley Blue Book, 2016 Tesla Model S specs.

The 2016 Tesla Model S at a glance

CAREFUL: Serious complaints 2.3× usual, mostly suspension and steering.

EnginesElectric
DriveAWD, RWD
Fuel economy89–104 MPGe
NHTSA crash rating5 of 5
Recalls10
Owner complaints649
Most-reported problemSuspension (211 complaints)

2016 Tesla Model S recalls

Check a car's VIN for open recalls (NHTSA).

Compared with the years around it

201520162017
EnginesElectricElectricElectric
Fuel economy89–101 MPGe89–104 MPGe95–104 MPGe
Crash rating5 of 55 of 5Not rated
Recalls9109
Owner complaints668649428
Apple CarPlay———
Used asking price$15,600
104,000 mi
$18,700
113,000 mi
$20,100
95,000 mi
Our verdictCAREFULCAREFULCAREFUL

Every Model S year side by side

Which years have…

Wireless phone chargingThird row (7+ seats)AWD or 4WDPower liftgateHybrid, plug-in hybrid or electricFully electricAdaptive cruise with stop and goLane centeringBlind-spot monitoringHeated front seatsHeated second-row seatsVentilated (cooled) seatsHeated steering wheelLeather seatsRemote startSunroof or moonroofPanoramic roof
Every NHTSA-rated 2016 version: crash ratings, safety tech, recalls, complaints
YearVersionStarsForward collision warning Lane departure warningRecallsComplaints
2016 Tesla Model S 60 5 HB RWD Later ReleaseNot Rated NoNo 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 60 5 HB RWD Early Release5 StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 60D 5 HB AWD Later ReleaseNot Rated NoNo 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 60D 5 HB AWD Early ReleaseNot Rated StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 70 5 HB RWD5 StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 70D 5 HB AWD5 StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 75 5 HB RWD Later ReleaseNot Rated NoNo 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 75 5 HB RWD Early Release5 StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 75D 5 HB AWD Later ReleaseNot Rated NoNo 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 75D 5 HB AWD Early ReleaseNot Rated StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 85 5 HB RWD5 StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 85D 5 HB AWDNot Rated StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 90 5 HB RWD5 StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 90D 5 HB AWD Later ReleaseNot Rated NoNo 8604
2016 Tesla Model S 90D 5 HB AWD Early ReleaseNot Rated StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S P100D 5 HB AWD Later ReleaseNot Rated NoNo 8604
2016 Tesla Model S P100D 5 HB AWD Early ReleaseNot Rated StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S P85D 5 HB AWDNot Rated StandardStandard 8604
2016 Tesla Model S P90D 5 HB AWD Later ReleaseNot Rated NoNo 8604
2016 Tesla Model S P90D 5 HB AWD Early ReleaseNot Rated StandardStandard 8604

Source: NHTSA.

Every EPA-rated 2016 version: engines and combined mpg
YearEPA modelEnginesCombined
2016Model S (60 kW-hr battery pack)Auto (A1) 99
2016Model S (70 kW-hr battery pack)Auto (A1) 89
2016Model S (75 kW-hr battery pack)Auto (A1) 98
2016Model S (85 kW-hr battery pack)Auto (A1) 89
2016Model S (90 kW-hr battery pack)Auto (A1) 89
2016Model S AWD - 60DAuto (A1) 104
2016Model S AWD - 70DAuto (A1) 101
2016Model S AWD - 75DAuto (A1) 103
2016Model S AWD - 85DAuto (A1) 100
2016Model S AWD - 90DAuto (A1) 103
2016Model S AWD - P100DAuto (A1) 98
2016Model S AWD - P85DAuto (A1) 93
2016Model S AWD - P90DAuto (A1) 95

Source: fueleconomy.gov.

Compare with another vehicle