About Model Year Matters
Model Year Matters helps you know exactly which year and trim to buy, for every car since 2010. It is independent and free. The same car can be a great buy one year and a headache the next, and the feature you want might only come on one trim, so we lay out every model year and trim side by side.
What you'll find here
- Year by year for every model since 2010: engines, fuel economy, crash ratings, recalls, owner complaints and the problem owners reported most.
- Trims and features: which trims have heated seats, wireless CarPlay, a third row and more, standard or optional, and the answer across years (Find by feature).
- Which year to buy: our verdict on each year for a growing list of models (Buyer guides), and the Model Year Matters videos.
How we judge a model year
Verdicts are computed from NHTSA data by fixed rules, the same for every model:
- Serious complaints. We count owner complaints to NHTSA about safety-critical parts (engine, power train, fuel system, brakes, steering, air bags, speed control, collision avoidance, suspension, structure, stability control) or that involved a crash, fire, injury or death.
- Per car on the road, against the same model year. For each year we take the model's share of all serious complaints about vehicles of that model year, divide it by its share of those vehicles on the road, and compare the result with the model's usual year. Comparing within a model year takes out age (older cars have had longer to collect complaints) and the rise in complaints NHTSA receives (far more since 2022); dividing by cars on the road means a year that sold more isn't marked down for it. Cars on the road come from New York State's registrations (every registered vehicle's VIN, decoded with NHTSA's VIN decoder); a model we can't match there goes by its share of complaints alone. A model's usual year is measured over its years up to 10 years old. Older years are put on the same scale: the cars from those years still on the road are the ones that lasted, which spreads the numbers wider, so each older model year is calibrated against every model of that year.
- Avoid: at least 2.5 times the usual share, with at least 25 serious complaints. Careful: at least 1.6 times, or 1.2 times with an open or past NHTSA defect investigation (a preliminary evaluation, engineering analysis or recall query) into a serious part. Best buy: the one year, on sale at least 3 years, with the lowest share, at most three quarters of the usual. Too new: on sale less than a year and a half. Few reports: NHTSA has no owner complaints on file for the year at all, so there is nothing to rate; it is left out of the model's usual year. Everything else is a good buy. A high or low count must also be too far from the usual to be chance (a Poisson test), so a model with few complaints isn't judged on a handful.
- What it can't see. New York's mix of cars isn't the whole country's (fewer pickups, more all-wheel drive), which matters less when comparing years of one model, and counts are only as good as the VIN decoding; that's why only large differences count. Complaints are about safety and major failures, not comfort or infotainment annoyances, and owners file more after a recall makes news (we note when many did). It isn't a survey of owners like Consumer Reports'; it's what owners told the government, compared fairly across years.
Models with a video have our full research behind the verdicts, which can weigh things the numbers can't, like a known fix partway through a year.
Where the numbers come from
- Trims, prices, features and options: OpenSpec by Visor (release 2026-11-16), built from manufacturer order guides and spec sheets. Contains information from OpenSpec, made available under the ODbL 1.0. For makes OpenSpec doesn't cover yet, the manufacturers' own published order guides, equipment guides and brochures (linked on each model year's page).
- Trims, base prices, seating and driver-assistance equipment for every make: NHTSA's vehicle database (vPIC).
- Owner complaints, recalls and crash ratings: NHTSA. Complaints are unverified reports from owners and aren't adjusted for how many cars were sold.
- Engines and fuel economy: EPA, fueleconomy.gov.
Horsepower: the maker's rating as filed with the EPA (its
test car list),
OpenSpec's trims, or the maker's own press pages (
data/hp_overrides.tomlcites each); where none confirms an engine's figure, the page shows the engine without one. - Cars on the road: New York State DMV registrations (open data), counted by model and year; we keep only the counts.
- Fixes and extended coverage: manufacturers' service bulletins, warranty extensions and repair programs as filed with NHTSA.
- Used-car asking prices: ForCar (forcar.org), CC BY 4.0. The average asking price and mileage of used cars listed for sale in the US since June 2026, by model and model year (a year needs at least 5 cars; each car is counted once). These are asking prices, not what cars sold for. We refresh them weekly and round to $100 and 1,000 miles; each figure links to its ForCar price page.
- CarPlay model years: Apple.
- Photos: from Wikimedia Commons under free licenses, found through Wikipedia's articles on each generation; the photographer and license are under each photo.
- Make logos: one-color versions of the logos in the open car-logos-dataset. Logos are trademarks of their owners, shown only to identify each make; we aren't affiliated with or endorsed by any manufacturer.
Specs and equipment vary by build. Always check the window sticker or the specific car you're buying.
How we make money
Model Year Matters is free to use and supported by advertising and affiliate links: when a link takes you to a listing site or a vehicle history report and you buy or sign up, we may earn a commission, at no cost to you. Those links are labeled. No one pays us to change a verdict or a ranking, and manufacturers and dealers have no say in what we publish.
Contact
Questions, corrections or partnership requests: hello@modelyearmatters.com. Found a mistake in OpenSpec's trim data? The same correction helps everyone at openspec.visor.vin.
Download the data
The vehicle data this site serves is open under the ODbL 1.0:
the model index, plus one file per model (data/models/<model>.json) and per model year
(data/models/<model>/<year>.json). Our page design, text, verdicts and videos are not part of it.