Model Year Matters

2012 Tesla Model S

Hatchback · 2012–2026

Which year to buy

Too new to judge: 2026. Give a new year a year or two of owner reports.

Used asking price: about $12,600 (average of 19 cars listed since June 2026, about 131,000 miles). Asking prices, not sale prices. Source: ForCar

Bar height: serious owner complaints to NHTSA for that year per car on the road, against this model's usual year.

2012GOOD BUYSerious complaints 0.9× usual

21 serious complaints of 61, the most about suspension (9) and power train (5); per car on the road, 0.9× this model's usual year. Only 38 of these cars are registered in New York, so the comparison per car is rough. 8 recalls. NHTSA investigation EA21002: desiccated air bag inflator rupture.

What owners report

“You are investigating tesla front suspension failures. You should also investigate tesla rear suspension failures. Here is just one recent example.https://www.iaai.com/vehicledetails/38453571?rownumber=39 the suspension link has snapped like a pretzel causing the suspension to flop down like a bad case of brewer's droop.”

An owner's complaint to NHTSA about the suspension, Dec 2020

“The drive unit has water damage from normal driving. The car never went through deep water or was flooded, but the tech at the service center is saying the units are sealed but still can get water in them and corrode. How can a vital sealed part of the vehicle be damaged by normal driving and claim water damage?”

An owner's complaint to NHTSA about the power train, Mar 2023

When problems show up

Half of the 15 serious complaints that gave a mileage came before 65,000 miles.

From owner complaints to NHTSA that gave a mileage.

61 owner complaints · 8 recalls (check a car's VIN for open recalls) · EPA combined: 89 mpg · NHTSA: — · 2012 trims and features

Every Model S year's verdict

Verdicts computed from NHTSA owner complaints, defect investigations and recalls. Cars on the road from New York State registrations. (How we judge.) Data checked 2026-10-24.

Trims and features

201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023202420252026

What changed for 2012

First year we have trim data for.

2012 Model S trims

406085P85SignatureSignature Performance
Price
Starting MSRP$57,400$67,400$77,400$92,400$95,400$105,400
Powertrain
Horsepower——362 hp416 hp362 hp416 hp
Torque——325 lb-ft443 lb-ft325 lb-ft443 lb-ft
DrivetrainRWDRWDRWDRWDRWDRWD
Electric range——265 mi265 mi265 mi265 mi
Performance
0-60 mph (maker's claim)6.5 s5.9 s5.6 s4.4 s5.6 s4.4 s
Top speed (maker's claim)110 mph120 mph125 mph130 mph125 mph130 mph
Size and capability
Seats5 + option5 + option5 + option5 + option5 + option5 + option
Cargo behind last row26.3 cu ft26.3 cu ft26.3 cu ft26.3 cu ft26.3 cu ft26.3 cu ft
Max cargo58.1 cu ft58.1 cu ft58.1 cu ft58.1 cu ft58.1 cu ft58.1 cu ft
Ground clearance6 in6 in6 in6 in6 in6 in
Length196 in196 in196 in196 in196 in196 in
Curb weight————4,647 lb4,643 lb
Tech
Touchscreen17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in17 in
Apple CarPlayOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional——
Android AutoOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional——
Speakers7 + option7 + option7 + option7 + option1212
Comfort
SeatsOptionalOptionalOptionalLeather + optionLeather + optionLeather + option
Heated seats———FrontFrontFront
Driver seat memory———Driver SeatDriver SeatDriver Seat
Climate zones222222
Remote startApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote StartApp-Based Remote Start
Exterior
Wheels19 in + option19 in + option19 in + option21 in + option21 in + option21 in + option
Tire size245/45R19 + option245/45R19 + option245/45R19 + option245/35R21 + option245/35R21 + option245/35R21 + option
HeadlightsHalogen + optionHalogen + optionHalogen + optionHalogen + optionBi-Xenon ProjectorBi-Xenon Projector
Packages and options (26)
406085P85SignatureSignature Performance
Sound Studio package $950OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalStandardStandard
Tech Package $3,750OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalStandardStandard
Twin Chargers $1,500OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalStandardStandard
All Glass Panoramic Roof $1,500OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
High Power Wall Connector $1,200OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Parcel shelf $250OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalStandardStandard
Built-in rear-facing child seats $1,500OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
19-inch aluminum alloy wheels StandardStandardStandardOptionalOptionalOptional
21-inch performance carbon gray aluminum alloy wheels ———Standard—Standard
21-inch Silver aluminum alloy wheels OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalStandardOptional
Metallic Blue $750OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Metallic Brown $750OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Metallic Green $750OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Metallic Grey $750OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Metallic Silver $750OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Tesla Multi-coat Pearl White $1,500OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Solid Black OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Solid White OptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptionalOptional
Black Nappa Leather $1,500OptionalOptionalOptional———
Black Nappa Leather with Alcantara Accents ———Optional——
Black Textile OptionalOptionalOptional———
Grey Nappa Leather $1,500OptionalOptionalOptional———
Grey Nappa Leather with Alcantara Accents ———Optional——
Signature White Leather ————OptionalOptional
Tan Nappa Leather $1,500OptionalOptionalOptional———
Tan Nappa Leather with Alcantara Accents ———Optional——

Trim data from OpenSpec (ODbL 1.0), built from Oem configurator, Oem brochure, Nhtsa vin decode, Oem configurator, Oem configurator. Still partial for this year: model, trims, powertrain, fuel economy, chassis, dimensions, exterior, interior, infotainment, safety, warranty, options, option rules, vin decode. "Optional" means a package or option adds it; tap for which.

The 2012 Tesla Model S at a glance

GOOD BUY: Serious complaints 0.9× usual.

EnginesElectric
DriveRWD
Fuel economy89 MPGe
Recalls8
Owner complaints61
Most-reported problemElectrical system (37 complaints)

2012 Tesla Model S recalls

Check a car's VIN for open recalls (NHTSA).

Compared with the years around it

20122013
EnginesElectricElectric
Fuel economy89 MPGe89–95 MPGe
Crash rating—5 of 5
Recalls811
Owner complaints61461
Apple CarPlay——
Used asking price$12,600
131,000 mi
$12,500
163,000 mi
Our verdictGOOD BUYCAREFUL

Every Model S year side by side

Which years have…

Wireless phone chargingThird row (7+ seats)AWD or 4WDPower liftgateHybrid, plug-in hybrid or electricFully electricAdaptive cruise with stop and goLane centeringBlind-spot monitoringHeated front seatsHeated second-row seatsVentilated (cooled) seatsHeated steering wheelLeather seatsRemote startSunroof or moonroofPanoramic roof
Every EPA-rated 2012 version: engines and combined mpg
YearEPA modelEnginesCombined
2012Model SAuto (A1) 89

Source: fueleconomy.gov.

Compare with another vehicle