Which year to buy
No owner complaints on file, so nothing to rate: 2016, 2023–2025.
Used asking price: about $13,600 (average of 13 cars listed since June 2026, about 114,000 miles). Asking prices, not sale prices. Source: ForCar
Bar height: serious owner complaints to NHTSA for that year per car on the road, against this model's usual year.
2010CAREFULSerious complaints 4.2× usual, mostly power train and engine and engine cooling Extended coverage
60 serious complaints of 62, the most about power train (42) and engine and engine cooling (13); per car on the road, 4.2× this model's usual year. Only 92 of these cars are registered in New York, so the comparison per car is rough.
What owners report
“While driving in rush hour bumper to bumper traffic the 2010 audi s4 with the dsg s-tronic transmission becomes very jerky, causing it to surge when starting and stopping or driving at low speeds. As a result it is hard to control, especially in tight traffic, parking areas, or around pedestrians.”
An owner's complaint to NHTSA about the power train, Aug 2014
“While driving home from newark airport on nj turnpike at 1 a.m., the water pump failed on my 2010 audi s4. The coolant warning indicated a problem. I made it to a service area within a few miles. I did not want to stop on the side of the road. I opened the hood and found coolant splattered all over the engine with steam rising up.”
An owner's complaint to NHTSA about the engine and engine cooling, Nov 2010
When problems show up
Half of the 55 serious complaints that gave a mileage came before 57,000 miles.
Power train (39 serious complaints): half came before 63,000 miles; 10% within a typical 36,000-mile new-car warranty.
Engine and engine cooling (11 serious complaints): half came before 9,800 miles; 100% within a typical 36,000-mile new-car warranty.
From owner complaints to NHTSA that gave a mileage.
Fixes and extended coverage
- Extended coverage General information on the upcoming warranty extension on the high pressure fuel pump. (Dealer, Apr 2015)
- Extended coverage New DSG transmission warranty extension for 2010-2012 S4 & S5 vehicles (AWA 22, Apr 2022)
From the manufacturer's bulletins filed with NHTSA. A dealer can look up whether a car has had the work done or is still covered.
62 owner complaints · 0 recalls · EPA combined: 21 mpg · NHTSA: Not rated · 2010 trims and features
Verdicts computed from NHTSA owner complaints, defect investigations and recalls. Cars on the road from New York State registrations. (How we judge.) Data checked 2026-10-24.
Trims and features
What changed for 2010
First year we have trim data for.
2010 S4 trims
| Premium Plus | Prestige | |
|---|---|---|
| Powertrain | ||
| Drivetrain | AWD | AWD |
| Size and capability | ||
| Seats | 5 | 5 |
| Tech | ||
| Audio | — | Bang & Olufsen |
| Comfort | ||
| Heated seats | Front | — |
Packages and options (9)
| Premium Plus | Prestige | |
|---|---|---|
| Brilliant Black | — | — |
| Deep Sea Blue pearl effect | — | — |
| Ibis White | — | — |
| Ice Silver metallic | — | — |
| Imola Yellow | — | — |
| Meteor Gray pearl effect | — | — |
| Phantom Black pearl effect | — | — |
| Quartz Gray metallic | — | — |
| Sprint Blue pearl Effect | — | — |
Trim data from OpenSpec (ODbL 1.0), built from Nhtsa vin decode. Still partial for this year: model, trims, powertrain, dimensions, exterior, interior, infotainment, options, vin decode. "Optional" means a package or option adds it; tap for which.
The 2010 Audi S4 at a glance
CAREFUL: Serious complaints 4.2× usual, mostly power train and engine and engine cooling.
| Engines | 3.0L 6-cyl supercharged, 333 hp manual available |
|---|---|
| Drive | AWD |
| Fuel economy | 21 mpg |
| NHTSA crash rating | Not rated |
| Recalls | 0 |
| Owner complaints | 62 |
| Most-reported problem | Power train (42 complaints) |
| Apple CarPlay | No |
Compared with the years around it
| 2010 | 2011 | |
|---|---|---|
| Engines | 3.0L 6-cyl supercharged, 333 hp manual available | 3.0L 6-cyl supercharged, 333 hp manual available |
| Fuel economy | 21 mpg | 21 mpg |
| Crash rating | Not rated | 4 of 5 |
| Recalls | 0 | 1 |
| Owner complaints | 62 | 26 |
| Apple CarPlay | No | No |
| Used asking price | $13,600 114,000 mi | $11,000 119,000 mi |
| Our verdict | CAREFUL | CAREFUL |
Which years have…
Every NHTSA-rated 2010 version: crash ratings, safety tech, recalls, complaints
| Year | Version | Stars | Forward collision warning | Lane departure warning | Recalls | Complaints |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 | Audi S4 4-DR. w/SAB | Not Rated | Optional | No | 0 | 60 |
| 2010 | Audi S4 Avant Wagon 4-DR. w/SAB | Not Rated | Optional | No | 0 | 60 |
Source: NHTSA.
Every EPA-rated 2010 version: engines and combined mpg
| Year | EPA model | Engines | Combined |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 | S4 | Auto (S7), 6 cyl, 3.0 L, Sup Charg Man 6-spd, 6 cyl, 3.0 L, Sup Charg |
21 |
Source: fueleconomy.gov.